German TV annual vehicle inspection report released: Tesla Model Y has the lowest reliability for two consecutive years

📅 2026-11-22

Abstract:

The German TUV Association recently released the annual vehicle inspection report (TUV-Report 2027). In an evaluation of 109 models that were 2 to 3 years old,

Tesla Model Y ranked at the bottom with a major or dangerous defect rate of 18.5%. This is the second consecutive year it has been at the bottom, and it is higher than the 17.3% in the previous year, while the average for the same age group is only 6.4%.


TUV stated that since its 2015 annual report, no 2- to 3-year-old model has experienced such a high rate of major defects.

According to reports, this report is based on approximately 9.7 million vehicle inspection data completed by German TUV inspection stations from July 1, 2025 to June 30, 2026.

Calculated, nearly 1 out of every 5 Model Y vehicles undergoing the first periodic technical inspection was found to have major or dangerous defects that need to be addressed.

In terms of specific issues, the most prominent shortcoming of Model Y is the suspension system. The detection frequency of defects such as wear and looseness of the ball joints and guide joints is 24 times that of the comparison models.

The braking system also performed poorly. 3.4% of Model Ys were found to have brake disc defects, while the average for the same age group was only 1.0%. The proportion of front lighting system failures was also higher than the average.

It should be pointed out that the average mileage of the Model Y tested reached 58,000 kilometers, which was higher than the average of 47,000 kilometers in the same group.

In addition,

Tesla Model 3's performance was also not ideal, ranking third from the bottom with a defect rate of 12.5%.

In the 6- to 7-year-old group, Model 3 also ranked last with a defect rate of 27.9%, and the average for this group was 13.2%. SAIC MG4 ranked second from the bottom with a defect rate of 16.0%, becoming the first Chinese brand model to enter TUV's annual report. The main problem is also concentrated on the brake disc.

It is worth mentioning that the low ranking is not a common performance of electric vehicles.

A total of 26 pure electric vehicles in the 2 to 3-year-old age group participated in the evaluation. Four electric vehicles, Mazda MX-30, Audi Q8 e-tron, Mini Cooper SE and Mercedes-Benz EQA, were among the top ten in the overall list.

The championship in this category was won by the Mazda CX-60 with a defect rate of 2.3%.

Joachim Bühler, general manager of the TUV Association, explained that suspension and brakes are common problems for electric vehicles. The weight of the battery continues to press the suspension, and kinetic energy recovery greatly reduces the frequency of mechanical brake use, which can easily lead to brake disc corrosion.

ADAC also pointed out that Tesla does not set maintenance cycles, and many defects are not discovered until annual inspections, which also affects the statistical results to a certain extent.


Related tags

Related articles

Comments

0/500
Captcha (click to refresh)
No comments yet