Abstract:
Halte à l'Obsolescence Programmée (HOP), a French consumer rights organization, announced this week that Apple will go on trial in France in June 2027, accusing it of restricting independent repairers from repairing iPhones.

The case stems from a complaint filed by HOP in December 2022, targeting Apple's "parts matching" mechanism. This mechanism will electronically bind components such as screens, batteries, cameras, etc. to specific iPhones. HOP alleges that when users or third-party repairers perform repairs outside Apple's authorized channels, even if original Apple parts are used, the replaced screens, batteries, and cameras may malfunction.
According to materials released by HOP, this complaint covers 24 iPhone models and involves repair practices between November 2021 and July 2024. Although HOP characterized the case as a matter of "planned obsolescence", the actual prosecution under French consumer law was obstructing repairs and renovations.
Apple denied the accusations in a statement to Le Monde, calling them baseless. Apple also emphasized that the company has lifted some restrictions, including allowing third parties to continue to use the True Tone display function after replacing the screen.
Since the complaint was filed, Apple has expanded support for used original parts, initially to iPhone 15 and newer models. Apple said the parts pairing mechanism is designed to protect user privacy, security and device security. HOP admits that Apple has indeed made some adjustments, but believes that the actual effect of these measures still needs to be tested by time.
Currently, the case has been scheduled for a procedural hearing on February 25, 2027, and several days of court debate are expected to take place in June 2027.
Comments