France sues Apple over "planned obsolescence" charges, case to be heard in 2027

📅 2026-11-18

Abstract:

The French consumer rights organization Halte à l’Obsolescence Programmée (HOP) has made new progress in its complaint against Apple. After several years of investigation, French prosecutors decided to take Apple to the Paris Criminal Court. The case revolves around so-called "planned obsolescence" and restrictions on equipment repairs.

This dispute can be traced back to December 2022, when HOP submitted a complaint to the relevant French authorities, accusing Apple of artificially restricting product repairs through software and hardware means, thereby shortening the effective service life of the device. France officially launched an investigation in May 2023. Today, HOP announced that Apple will undergo judicial proceedings on related charges.

According to HOP, Apple is suspected of using hardware and software technology to hinder third-party repairs. The organization pointed out that Apple will use chips to associate parts and peripherals in iPhone and other products with device serial numbers. When the system detects that the parts have been replaced, if the repair operation is not performed by an Apple-approved service organization, the device may malfunction. This type of practice has been deemed illegal after France revised its consumer code in 2021.

HOP further stated that it is aware of some cases where even if official parts that are exactly the same as the original parts are used during repair, the equipment may still malfunction or have limited functions after replacement. The organization believes this reflects Apple's failure to provide due support for such repairs.

Apple has long used a management mechanism called "serialized parts." This mechanism allows companies to verify the origin and fit of parts installed in equipment while limiting unauthorized repairs. In addition to requiring repairs to be completed by authorized agencies, Apple will also restrict authorized repairers from using uncertified parts.

Apple has always emphasized that such measures are designed to ensure that replacement parts are compatible with the device and to ensure product safety and user experience. In order to promote the establishment of legal repair channels, Apple has launched a self-service repair program, allowing users to purchase official parts and tools for repairs. It is worth noting that Apple launched the program in France on December 6, 2022, and HOP’s complaint was submitted the next day.

As of now, Apple France has not publicly commented on the Paris prosecutor’s decision to file a lawsuit.

According to published information, the Paris Criminal Court will hold a hearing on the case on February 25, 2027. By then, further judicial rulings are expected on disputes surrounding Apple's repair policy, serialized parts mechanism, and whether it constitutes "planned obsolescence."

Related tags

Related articles

Comments

0/500
Captcha (click to refresh)
No comments yet