Abstract:
Relevant media learned that a senior Democratic member of Congress warned that if the Trump administration and Musk refused to disclose who ordered the speed limit for Ukraine’s military Starshield satellite service, members would withhold government funding for the system developed by Musk’s SpaceX. Democratic Congressman Jim Himes, who will serve as chairman of the House Intelligence Committee in January next year, sent a confidential document to Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton. Relevant media obtained excerpts of the confidential documents, and Heims asked to clarify the reasons why Ukraine's Star Shield connection has been speed-limited many times in recent months.

He wrote to Clayton: "Simply put, if the government does not have full control of this system, this committee cannot fund its research and development projects. I need your help to promote information transparency so that we can have the confidence to continue to approve project funds for which SpaceX is a major supplier."
More and more Democratic congressmen have expressed their intention to investigate the restrictions on Ukraine's Star Shield system, which Ukraine's defense highly relies on. The service has previously experienced two rounds of speed restrictions that lasted for several days, but it has not been clear who issued the order. Democratic members of the House and Senate said that after the Democrats take control of Congress in January next year, they will comprehensively review the Trump administration’s arrangements with Russia.
As Hyams advances the investigation, Zelensky recently stated that Star Shields has once again encountered restrictions on its use; even though Trump met with Putin earlier this week, Ukraine is still suffering from a new round of large-scale attacks by Russia. Relevant media obtained another letter stating that Himes had formally requested to meet with Musk to discuss the speed limit incident.
Heims’ letter to Musk wrote: “My request is very clear. Please explain what adjustments have been made to the Star Shield service in October 2026, the reasons for the adjustments, and whether these changes were implemented unilaterally by SpaceX or ordered by US government officials.”
"I have expressed my view to senior government officials: SpaceX may unilaterally modify U.S. government contracts and fail to respond to congressional oversight. This will put a question mark on all contracts signed by the U.S. government and SpaceX, including what you said are independent military systems owned and controlled by the U.S. government."
Sources said that after Himes takes office as chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, one of his first tasks will be to investigate Musk's control of SpaceX military systems such as Star Shields; when necessary, he will use budget approval powers to force companies to explain speed limit incidents.
The core tool available to Himes is the "fund ring-fencing" mechanism, in which intelligence authorization bills legally restrict funding for specific projects until relevant questions are answered. If companies and the Trump administration continue to refuse to cooperate, he can also coordinate with the appropriations committee to withhold and transfer new funds for the SpaceX project.
Haims said that this confidential document to the Director of National Intelligence and the open letter to SpaceX mainly focus on two points: first, the facts are unclear about who made the decision to harm Ukraine’s defense capabilities; second, relevant government departments and SpaceX have not cooperated with parliamentarians’ inquiries so far.
Restrictions lasted for several weeks in October. At the beginning of this month, Zelensky said that restrictions had been reintroduced in the occupied territories of Ukraine for more than a week. Denis Sionnik, Ukraine's top diplomat in the United States, told relevant media on Friday that Ukraine has been communicating with the Pentagon but has not received a reply from SpaceX.
SpaceX holds billions of dollars in U.S. government space project contracts and plays a key role in the U.S. national security system. The contract is a bargaining chip in the hands of lawmakers, but using appropriations to sanction SpaceX also carries the risk of damaging irreplaceable space assets on which the United States' own defense depends.
The Trump administration, Musk and SpaceX executives have different opinions on how Star Shields speed limits are authorized. The speed limit caused the interruption of Ukraine's military Internet. This system is a key infrastructure for the Ukrainian army to launch missile and drone strikes and defend against Russian attacks.
Star Shield's first round of problems were discovered in mid-October. At that time, the Trump administration threatened to suspend the provision of intelligence to Kyiv because of Ukraine's attack on Russian oil refineries. At the same time, Trump reached an agreement to purchase Russian diesel and relax sanctions against Russia. Trump has feuded with Zelensky and suggested Ukraine should change its leader.
Reports related to the Star Shield speed limit caused confusion within the White House. Many officials did not know at first whether the US government was involved. Relevant media previously reported that the Senate Foreign Affairs Committee also plans to launch an investigation after the Democratic Party takes control of Congress. The top Democratic Party leader who is outgoing and will become the new chairman of the committee sent a letter to Musk last week asking SpaceX to retain all documents related to this service interruption.
Trump’s advisers had previously known that he was dissatisfied with Zelensky, but they had not heard that the president had specific plans to limit Ukraine’s ability to attack Russian refineries. Trump blamed such attacks for rising oil prices. Trump told officials he wanted to get to the bottom of the speed limit, but later said he did not personally issue the order. Officials within the government understand that the president ordered an investigation into the speed limit incident.
People familiar with the matter revealed that SpaceX executives and Defense Department officials privately told some lawmakers that the October speed limit originally came from the White House, but Trump has repeatedly denied his direct involvement. Ultimately, senior Trump administration officials pinned the blame on the private company, citing adjustments made under its terms of service to Ukraine.
Sources said that most of this set of terms of service for Ukraine are classified. There are many additional conditions for Ukraine's use of Star Shield. Ukraine's use of this system is highly dependent on the US's permission, and the terms of the contract are clearly bound by this.
The source admitted that there are "Musk variables" in the Pentagon's Star Shield cooperation with SpaceX. Musk has extremely high authority in the company and can adjust project settings from top to bottom. But Star Shield itself is a government-managed project.
"SpaceX operates the system on behalf of the U.S. government, but mission scheduling, usage rights, and access objects are completely controlled by the U.S. side." A U.S. official emphasized that Star Shield is a Pentagon system and needs to be distinguished from SpaceX's commercial Starlink service for the public.
However, a Pentagon official told relevant media that Defense Secretary Hegseth was not involved and had no prior knowledge, making the party responsible for the incident even more confusing. The official said: "He was completely unaware of this incident when it happened."
When the speed limit was first revealed, many Trump administration officials accused Musk of acting without authorization, calling it "overstepping his authority." A senior U.S. official said at the time that Trump did not issue a Star Shield speed limit order; another U.S. official insisted that Musk made the decision unilaterally.
Members of both parties are worried that Musk has huge authority over government control systems such as Star Shield and may unilaterally formulate foreign policy for the United States. Members of both parties had previously requested the Pentagon Inspector General to investigate the speed limit incident and verify whether the incident, combined with an early missile warning failure, endangered the safety of U.S. personnel. However, the Pentagon Inspector General rejected the request and asked members to ask the corresponding military services.
Haims said in an interview with relevant media this week: "There are two possibilities: Either this is a serious violation and a violation of the Pentagon contract; or SpaceX has the right to do this but did not inform anyone in advance. We must find out the truth, this matter is of great importance."
In his letter to Musk, he emphasized that if a satisfactory answer is not obtained, the approval of all SpaceX-related government project funds will be at risk. "Until I receive satisfactory answers to the questions regarding Star Shield services in Ukraine, it will be difficult for me to continue to support the approval of funding for these systems developed by SpaceX and owned by the U.S. Government."
Related articles:
Musk talks about the Starlink controversy in Ukraine and emphasizes that Starlink should not be used for offensive military operations
Comments