Huawei failed to prove its accusations in court, saying U.S. prosecutors cast a "dark color" on normal business activities

📅 2026-11-18

Abstract:

On November 17, local time, Huawei ushered in the final stage of the criminal case trial at the Federal Court in Brooklyn, New York, USA. Huawei's defense lawyers said in their closing arguments that U.S. prosecutors portrayed the company's normal business activities as a series of deliberate criminal acts, but after nearly two months of evidence presentation, prosecutors still failed to prove the relevant charges.

Huawei lawyer Brian Heberlig said in front of the jury that the US prosecutors found Huawei guilty from the beginning, and then turned around to find evidence to support this conclusion. He pointed out that when the evidence did not fit the prosecution's original theory, the prosecutors constantly adjusted the way they explained the charges.

Heberlig said that prosecutors gave a "shady" interpretation of Huawei's business activities, portraying normal business transactions as well-planned criminal operations. He believes that the government is trying to package Huawei's decades of business activities into a long-term criminal conspiracy by selectively presenting some events.

This case mainly involves multiple criminal charges filed by the US government against Huawei. Prosecutors allege that Huawei deceived HSBC and other financial institutions by concealing its relationship with its Iranian business, allowing the relevant banks to unknowingly process U.S. dollar transactions involving its Iranian business. In addition, Huawei was accused of conspiring with five U.S. technology companies to steal trade secrets and was listed by prosecutors as a subject suspected of operating a criminal enterprise.

U.S. prosecutors believe that Huawei has formed a sustained pattern of illegal behavior over a period of 20 years, involving U.S. companies, the financial system, and government agencies. Prosecutor Meredith Arfa said in closing arguments the day before that the government had proven beyond reasonable doubt that Huawei was operating as a criminal enterprise and should be held accountable for its long-term behavior.

Huawei refuted these accusations one by one.

In response to accusations of Iranian business and bank fraud, Heberlig said that the relevant banks have long known that Huawei is conducting business in Iran and still actively choose to cooperate with Huawei. He believes that these financial institutions are seeking Huawei customers with a full understanding of the relevant risks, and there is no case of Huawei deceiving banks by concealing information.

Regarding the accusation of trade secret theft, Huawei lawyers believe that the prosecutors only selected individual incidents involving a small number of employees and spliced ​​them into a criminal conspiracy that lasted for 20 years. He pointed out that relevant incidents did not prove that Huawei had systematic theft of secrets at the enterprise level, and emphasized that the company's commercial success relies on engineering technology, investment and innovation, rather than stealing competitors' technology.

Heberlig said in his closing argument: "Huawei did not achieve what it does today by stealing, but achieved success by relying on its own strength."

The lawsuit dates back to 2018, when Huawei Chief Financial Officer Meng Wanzhou was detained on a U.S. arrest warrant in Vancouver, Canada, and the incident quickly evolved into a diplomatic dispute between the United States, China and Canada. The United States accused Meng Wanzhou of making false statements about Huawei's relationship with Skycom when introducing Huawei's Iran-related business to HSBC Bank.

In 2021, Meng Wanzhou reached a deferred prosecution agreement with US prosecutors and admitted that there were inaccuracies in relevant statements. Subsequently, the United States dropped the criminal charges against her, but the case against Huawei did not end there.

U.S. prosecutors previously alleged that Huawei used Skycom to obtain goods, technology and services restricted by U.S. sanctions to support its business in Iran and to transfer funds through the international banking system. Reuters previously reported that Skycom offered to sell embargoed HP computer equipment worth at least 1.3 million euros to Iran's largest mobile operator in 2010. Meng Wanzhou served as a member of Skycom's board of directors from 2008 to 2009.

The case also involves trade secret disputes between Huawei and a number of US technology companies. The U.S. government believes that the relevant behavior is not an isolated employee violation, but a series of criminal activities carried out by the company over a long period of time. Huawei believes that prosecutors repackaged existing commercial disputes into criminal conspiracy and exaggerated the nature and relevance of individual incidents.

The trial officially opened in September 2026. The prosecution summoned more than 60 witnesses, and the Huawei defense summoned about 15 witnesses. After nearly two months of trial, both sides have completed their closing arguments, and the jury is expected to begin deliberations and make a verdict on November 18.

If Huawei is ultimately found guilty, U.S. prosecutors may seek to confiscate property or proceeds obtained through illegal activities. Legal experts have previously pointed out that if all charges are true, Huawei may face hundreds of millions or even billions of dollars in economic penalties. The specific amount will depend on the court's determination of illegal gains and the severity of its conduct.

After many years, this case has become an important case in the technological and judicial disputes between China and the United States. As the jury is about to begin deliberations, whether Huawei can avoid criminal conviction in a U.S. court will become a core focus in the next phase of the case. The outcome of the case will also receive attention in the context of continued intensification of competition between China and the United States over artificial intelligence, semiconductors and high-tech industries.

At this time, the jury has not yet reached a verdict. Huawei's closing argument represents the defendant's explanation of the evidence and does not mean that the court has concluded that the U.S. prosecutors failed to prove the relevant charges.

Related articles:

Yu Chengdong: We have basically got rid of dependence on American technology. Huawei’s folding screen started earlier than Apple

Related tags

Related articles

Comments

0/500
Captcha (click to refresh)
No comments yet